Is that the right fuse setting you're looking it? RSTDISBL is a high fuse!

You're looking for the extended fuse setting, specifically the "SELFPRGEN" one. If that isn't on, then micronucleus is unable to actually write your newly uploaded program to the ATTiny85s flash memory.
For 'stock' ATTiny85s RSTDISBL would be off, as you'd never be able to program them without a high voltage programmer. But on the Digispark it should be on, as this lets the reset pin be used as an extra IO pin.
It looks like the stock defaults are out for - the clock is wrong (8Mhz internal instead of PLL), brownout isn't enabled (and brownout voltage set), self-programming is not enabled, external reset is enabled).
These are the fuse settings for digisparks...
Low fuse: 0xe1
High fuse: 0x5d
Extended fuse: 0xfeYou can see the difference between stock settings and these if you go onto the
Engbedded Atmel AVR Fuse Calculator, pick attiny85 from the dropdown, and look at the defaults. You can put these fuse settings in manually further down the page if you want to see the difference.